Five 9th District Democratic US House hopefuls respond to students’ questions
Candidates questioned by students from South, North, IU during Tuesday debate
By Christy Mullins 331-4266 | cmullins@heraldt.com
April 25, 2012
Five Democrats vying to represent Indiana’s 9th District in the U.S. House agreed across the board Tuesday that gas prices are too high, public education is worth the investment, and Hoosiers need jobs in a desperate way.
Their thoughts varied, however, on whether women’s health issues and clean energy were up to Congress to discuss. One candidate, especially, called both issues a waste of time.
“We’re never going to solve these problems,” John Griffin Miller said in Tuesday night’s 9th District candidate debate at Bloomington High School South.
Miller said abortion, contraceptives and other women’s health issues come up every election year to get people out to the polls.
And he said alternative energy is a “misappropriation of our attention.”
“We’re spending trillions right now to solve a problem that is not solvable,” he said, “while thousands of children in Africa are dying of diarrhea.”
All five Democratic candidates — Miller, Jonathan George, John Tilford, Robert Winningham and Shelli Yoder — participated in Tuesday night’s debate in the South auditorium.
Three young Democrats from South, Bloomington High School North and Indiana University asked questions about health care, the national deficit, public education, job creation, foreign policy, abortion, gas prices, climate change and the experience each candidate would bring to the table, if elected.
Mary Catherine Carmichael moderated the debate, which began promptly at 7 p.m. and lasted nearly two hours.
The debate, co-sponsored by the Monroe County Democratic Party and the Indiana University College Democrats, was structured more like a panel. Each candidate got less than a minute to answer each question, with no time for rebuttal.
The panel structure skewed a bit, however, when Shelli Yoder returned to the issue of women’s health.
“It doesn’t just come around every two years — it happens every day,” she said, addressing the panel and the audience all at once before answering an unrelated question.
Yoder
Yoder, a working mother, a “small-town Hoosier girl” and an associate professor in the IU Kelley School of Business, said she’ll represent middle-class working families if elected to the 9th District.
Yoder also described herself Tuesday as pro-teacher, and said teachers should be “invited to the table to discuss legislation that impacts teachers.”
She seemed most passionate about clean energy, renewable resources and “electric cars that will carry us through the 21st century.”
Yoder’s parents owned a small filling station that went under in the 1980s, she noted Tuesday.
“We are expecting something that’s finite to be infinite, and that’s not going to happen,” she said.
“One of the great things about the 9th District is its access to natural resources.”
Winningham
Robert Winningham, an economic developer by trade, said his experience would be crucial for creating jobs in the 9th District.
He circled back to job creation in nearly every answer.
On whether he supports the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Winningham said he’d keep and perfect what’s been passed: “As a job creator,” he said, “I know that when workers are ill or their children are ill at home, they’re not as productive in society.”
Winningham wants to bring growth and economic development to every city in the 9th District, he said, and cut programs that aren’t useful.
He prizes public education and thinks schools should teach the problem-solving skills that employers want — not teach to pass standardized tests.
“Teachers are being beaten up for those efforts,” he said.
George
Candidate Jonathan George, a retired Air Force brigadier general, said it’s embarrassing that all Americans can’t be covered by the kind of health care insurance he’s received with a 30-year military career. He supports the Affordable Care Act, but said it needs some adjustments still.
On the economy, George said major cities are doing fairly well. “It’s everyone between the Sierra Mountains and the Appalachian Mountains that are expected to be defensive linemen for our country,” he said.
George said making investments in everything from roads to research will help bring commerce back to the Midwest and the 9th District.
Tilford
John Tilford, a retired Army Reserve colonel, urged the audience to research each candidate and take note of his decades of public service in the 9th District.
On education, Tilford said student loans shouldn’t double, and it’s a “no brainer” that standardized tests are a “let-down” to the public education system.
He saluted Ivy Tech Bloomington Chancellor John Whikehart for changing curriculum at the community college based on what employers are looking for.
On global warming, Tilford said it’s both “not fiction” and “a world problem,” but “we can help find the solution.”
“Yes, it exists and it’s going to come back to haunt us,” he said. “That’s not the question. The question is, how bad is it going to get?”
Miller
John Miller, a nonprofit director and the only candidate who said he opposes spending money and time on climate change, introduced himself as a candidate running not for Congress, but against Congress.
He said Congress has been bought and paid for by corporations, and current members of Congress “will never look out for the 99 percent.”
Miller blames banks for problems in public education, wars, and unemployment.
He doesn’t believe the United States is in an economic crisis. He said it is a banking crisis.
“We didn’t have a famine. We didn’t have a disease. This is a banking problem — not a real external crisis,” he said. “Banks need to be broken up, and that’s what will bring the economy back.”
Voting
Early voting has begun for the primary election, set for May 8. The prevailing Democratic candidate will face first-term incumbent Republican U.S. Rep. Todd Young in the fall election.
See the article on the Hetald-Times webste (subscription required): Five 9th District Democratic US House hopefuls respond to students’ questions.